Skip to main content

Table 2 Women’s preferences for laparoscopic or abdominal hysterectomy

From: Women’s preference for laparoscopic or abdominal hysterectomy

 

 

Patientsa (n = 43)

Nurses (n = 39)

Test for differences

Desired information

 

1 [1–8]b

1 [1–10]b

p = 0.76

Desired involvement

 

3.4 [1–9]b

3 [1–10]b

p = 0.80

Preferred approach (after global information)

Prefers LH

36 (84)

29 (74)

p = 0.56

No preference

1 (2)

1 (3)

Prefers AH

6 (14)

9 (23)

Preferred approach (after detailed information)

Prefers LH

37 (86)

29 (76)c

p = 0.38

No preference

0

1 (3)

Prefers AH

6 (14)

8 (21)

Preferred approach (equal complications and no conversions)

Prefers LH

39 (91)

33 (92)c

p = 0.90

No preference

2 (5)

2 (6)

Prefers AH

2 (5)

1 (3)

Major complications

Maximum acceptable rate

0.5 [0–10]b

1.0 [0–10]b

p < 0.01

Conversions to laparotomy

Maximum acceptable rate

50 [0.1–99]b

10 [0.1–75]b

p < 0.01

Accepts doubled major complication rate in LH

Yes

31 (72)

17 (44)

p = 0.04

Maybe

6 (14)

16 (41)

No

6 (14)

6 (15)

Accepts conversion in LH in case needed

Yes

39 (91)

31 (79)

p = 0.18

Maybe

1 (2)

5 (13)

No

3 (7)

3 (8)

  1. AH abdominal hysterectomy, LH laparoscopic hysterectomy, Test for differences test for differences among patients and nurses, p p value for difference between groups using Mann–Whitney tests and chi-square tests as appropriate, Desired information desired amount of information on advantages and disadvantages of treatment options on a 1 to 10 visual analogue scale, where 1 represents most information, Desired involvement desired level of involvement in medical decision-making on a 1 to 10 visual analogue scale, where 1 represents most involvement.
  2. aIn the patients, the pre-operative preferences are shown.
  3. bMedian [range], and absolute numbers (percentage)
  4. cData from one and three nurses are missing, respectively