Feasibility and long-term efficacy of hysteroscopic myomectomy for myomas with intramural development by the use of non-electrical “cold” loops
© Springer-Verlag 2011
Received: 7 August 2011
Accepted: 4 October 2011
Published: 26 October 2011
This study aimed to assess the feasibility and the short- and long-term efficacy of hysteroscopic myomectomy for submucous myomas with intramural development [grade 1 (G1) and grade 2 (G2)] by using non-electrical “cold” loops and to verify the role of preoperative variables on surgical outcomes. Symptomatic (bleeding and infertility) premenopausal patients with the diagnosis of submucous myoma at transvaginal sonography, and with G1 and G2 grading at sonohysterography, were included in this prospective study. Hysteroscopic myomectomy was performed by the combined monopolar electrical slicing and traction-and-leverage manoeuvres by non-electrical “cold” loops. One hundred fifty-nine patients were recruited, and 169 procedures were performed. Operating time, fluid deficit, complications and complete resection at first procedure (perioperative outcomes) and persisting symptoms and additional surgery for persisting symptoms (long-term outcomes) were not significantly different for G1 vs. G2 myomas. Perioperative outcomes were significantly different when comparing myoma mean diameter <3.0 vs. ≥3.0 cm (75th percentile). Multivariate analysis and multiple regression analysis proved that myoma mean diameter was the only significant variable for surgical outcomes. Hysteroscopic myomectomy by non-electrical “cold” loops is an effective and efficient treatment for submucous myomas with intramural development. Myoma mean diameter is the only significant preoperative variable for perioperative outcome, while myoma grading loses its role as a prognostic factor.
Hysteroscopic myomectomy is an efficient and effective technique and is considered the standard of care for conservative surgical removal of symptomatic (bleeding and infertility) submucous myomas [1–3]. The size and the different grading (G) of intramural extension of submucous myomas determine the chance of a complete resection and are strictly related to the risk of intraoperative complications (haemorrhage, perforation and fluid overload) [4–8].
Resectoscopic myomectomy is usually performed by the slicing technique with electrical loops. This technique is optimal for intracavitary myomas (G0) but may lead to partial section of the myometrial fibres on the uterine wall when myomas have a partial (G1) or prevalent (G2) intramural development. Moreover, thermal injury by mono- or bipolar unmodulated pure cutting electrosurgery might extend to more than 1.0 mm [9, 10], with additional damage to the myometrium and to the endometrial cavity. This might lead to late fertility complications, such as intrauterine synechiae .
In mid-1990s, non-electrical loops (“cold loops”) were introduced as an additional tool for hysteroscopic myomectomy . The use of cold loops to enucleate the intramural portion of submucous myomas might avoid the unnecessary extensive electrical cut of surrounding myometrial fibres and the thermal injury of the adiacent myometrium. This “mechanical” approach minimises direct myometrial damage and unnecessary fibrosis in the area of surgical intervention. Recently, this pioneering technique has proved to be effective in a small series of large submucous myomas (≥5 cm) ; however, it has never been scrutinized in large and long-term prospective studies. The aim of this study was to assess the feasibility and the short- and long-term efficacy of the combined use of non-electrical “cold” loops and monopolar electrical loops for resectoscopic removal of G1 and G2 submucous myomas in a prospective series of symptomatic (bleeding and infertility) premenopausal patients.
Premenopausal patients complaining abnormal uterine bleeding and/or infertility with G1 and G2 myomas were consecutively recruited between January 2000 and December 2009. Relevant demographic data were recorded. The study design was approved by the institutional review board.
Number, site and size of myomas, the myometrial free margin and endometrial thickness and pattern were assessed by high-quality transvaginal sonography and saline contrast sonohysterography (SCSH). SCSH was always performed according to previously published 2D and 3D imaging criteria in order to preoperatively classify myoma grading [14, 15]. Grade 1 (G1) was defined as a sessile fibroid, with the endocavitary part protruding into the cavity dilated by saline solution ≥50%, and grade 2 (G2) with the endocavitary part <50% and prevalent intramural development. The myometrial free margin was considered the shortest distance between the outer margin of the myoma and the perimetrium as assessed by SCSH. Inclusion criteria were: number ≤3 and size ≤5 cm of submucous myomas and myometrial free margin ≥3 mm. The mean diameter of myomas was calculated from the three diameters: (d1 + d2 + d3)/3.
Medical preoperative treatment
GnRH analogue triptorelin or leuprorelin were prescribed for 2–3 months to patients with myomas >3 cm, in order to reduce myoma volume, to induce endometrial hypotrophy, and/or for patients suffering from secondary anaemia.
When no preoperative medication was prescribed, all patients underwent surgery in the early proliferative phase of the cycle. Resectoscopic procedures were performed using a rigid 8-mm (27 Fr) continous-flow resectoscope for intrauterine high-frequency electrosurgery with rotatable inner tube and a 12° fore-oblique telescope (Karl Storz GmbH & Co., Germany). The uterine cavity was distended and irrigated with a nonconductive, hypo-osmolar solution of 2.7% sorbitol and 0.54% mannitol, instilled under manometric control by a hysteroscopic pump. The basic fluid setting was: intrauterine pressure 50 mmHg (never exceeding 120 mmHg during surgery), in-flow 150 ml/min, aspiration pressure 0.2 bar. The lowest pressure compatible with a clear vision was used during the procedure by “tailoring” opening and closure of inflow and outflow stopcocks.
Operating time was considered as the time between initial insertion and final removal of the resectoscope. Fluid deficit was calculated as the difference between the total amount of instilled solution into the uterus and the amount of fluid recovered from the suction bottle and the plastic draping that funnelled escaping fluid through the cervix into a calibrated pouch. According to the AAGL guidelines , a strict fluid monitoring was assessed every 10–15 min. In cases exceeding 60 min of intervention and/or a fluid deficit >1,000 ml, intra-operative sonography was used to decide if the remaining part of the lesion might be removed in few additional minutes or if stopping the procedure.
A short-term preoperative antimicrobial prophylaxis with cephalosporins was administered to all patients (cefazolin 1 g i.v.). All the surgical procedures were performed by one senior hysteroscopist (F.P.G.L.) in a day-surgery regimen. Within 2 months after the procedure, a SCSH was scheduled to evaluate disease persistence and to exclude uterine cavity lesions.
Intra-operative surgical outcomes were considered as follows: operating time, fluid deficit, surgical complications and complete resection at first procedure. Fluid deficit >1,500 ml, perioperative haemorrhage and uterine perforation were considered as complications. Intrauterine lesions (synechiae) at follow-up and surgical and/or medical treatment for persisting uterine bleeding were considered as unfavourable long-term outcomes.
A telephone or direct interview follow-up after 6 and every 12 months was scheduled to assess menstrual pattern, pregnancy occurrence and outcome. All patients had at least a 1-year follow-up.
Demographic and baseline characteristics were analyzed by parametric and nonparametric descriptive statistics where appropriate. Continuous and dichotomous variables before and after surgery were compared using t test, nonparametric test and the Fisher’s exact test, respectively.
The 75th percentile of mean myoma diameters was used to define the categorical variable small/large myoma. A multivariate logistic analysis was performed to identify variables independently and significantly associated to surgical outcomes. Similarly, a multiple regression analysis was performed using myoma mean diameter and submucous myoma grading as continuous variables. Probability values less than 5% were considered significant. The time to event (abnormal uterine bleeding) analysis for all the patients was performed by the Kaplan–Meyer curve.
One hundred fifty-nine patients were recruited. Of these, 139 complained abnormal uterine bleeding, 6 were infertile and 14 had both symptoms. Median age (interquartile range) was 44 years (IR 35–48). Mean body mass index (±SD) was 24 ± 5 kg/m2. Mean parity (±SD) was 1 ± 1. The median mean myoma diameter was 2.1 cm (IR 1.6–3.0). Seventy-seven patients had additional intramural and/or subserous myomas and/or adenomyosis. Eighty-one patients (51%) received preoperative medical treatment with GnRH analogue.
One hundred sixty-nine resectoscopic procedures were performed. Overall, 196 G1–G2 myomas were removed. In the 20 patients with multiple submucous myomas, the worst grading degree was considered for data analysis. Seventy-three myomas were classified as G1 (46%) and 86 as G2 (54%). No women required perioperative blood transfusion. The histological report confirmed the diagnosis of leiomyoma in the vast majority of patients; only three cases of adenomyoma were reported. In 20 patients (13%), concomitant simple endometrial hyperplasia was reported.
Multivariate logistic regression analysis of perioperative and long-term surgical outcomes
Perioperative surgical outcomes (#159)
Long-term surgical outcomes (#153)
p > Chi2
p > Chi2
Age (>35 years)
Myoma pre-surgical mean diameter (≥3.0 cm)
Number of submucous myomas (>#1)
Preoperative GnRH analogue (yes)
Coexisting uterine lesions (yes)a
In order to strengthen the above results, a multiple regression analysis was performed. Myoma mean diameter and submucous myoma grading were considered as continuous variables in relation to both operating time and fluid deficit. By a 1-cm increase of the myoma mean diameter, a significant mean operating time increase of 9.6 min was observed (p ≤ 0.0001); conversely, a submucous myoma G2 required a not significant operative time increase of 4.4 min compared to a G1 (p = 0.25). Similarly, by a 1-cm increase of the myoma mean diameter, a significant mean fluid deficit increase of 190 ml was observed (p < 0.001); conversely, a G2 required a not significant fluid deficit increase of 100 ml compared to a G1 (p = 0.06).
Surgical outcomes of the whole study group (159 patients) and related to submucous myomas grading (G) and to myoma mean diameter (d)
d < 3.0 cm
d ≥ 3.0 cm
Operating time (min) (median – IR)
Fluid deficit (ml) (median – IR)
Complications, no. (%)
Complete resection at first procedure, no. (%)
We compared the first 50 consecutive procedures (learning curve period) with the remaining 119. Perioperative results in the learning period and at steady state were not significantly different both for G1 and G2 myomas and for myomas smaller and larger than 3 cm.
Ten patients (6%) were lost at follow-up.
At a median follow-up period of 63 months (IR 36–85), five patients required myomectomy and five hysterectomy for persisting symptoms. Intrauterine adhesions occurred in four of 156 patients (2.6%), which were successfully removed by office hysteroscopy. One patient showed at SCSH a myometrial defect due to electrical damage.
Nine of the 20 infertile patients conceived. Three patients delivered vaginally at term; three patients delivered by caesarean section for breech presentation, foetal macrosomia and foetal distress during labour. One twin pregnancy and one singleton complicated by pre-eclampsia were delivered preterm by caesarean section. One patient had a first trimester miscarriage.
In this prospective study of 159 premenopausal patients with G1 and G2 submucous myomas, we report the combined use of electrical (slicing) and non-electrical loops (enucleation) to respect myometrial fibres functional anatomy and to reduce intravasation and bleeding. We obtained excellent surgical results with a high rate of single step complete resection (88%) with minimal myometrial thermal injury with a negligible number of synechiae (2.6%) and myometrial lesions (0.6%). This compares well to the best reported results (1–12%) and to unpublished data by Mazzon [3, 11, 17].
In particular, the complete removal for G1 and G2 submucous myomas was 92% and 85%, respectively, not significantly different. This result was in line with the best results of previous studies reporting a complete removal by traditional monopolar slicing of 73–93% for G1 and 50–85% for G2, respectively [4, 6, 7, 18–21].
By means of cold loops traction-and-leverage technique itself, combined with a basic low intrauterine pressure setting (50 mmHg), complete resections were more easily achieved also in large myomas, with a limited number of complications. In fact, the maintenance of the integrity of myometrial fibres, particularly the function of archimetrial layer , and of myoma pseudocapsule permitted to avoid deep and larger myometrial vessels damage and to obtain adequate haemostatic myometrial contractions. This reduced the risk of fluid overload, achieving a median fluid deficit significantly lower than in previous studies [5, 7] and similar to those reported more recently  which might have adopted similar low intrauterine fluid pressure.
The need of repetitive changing of electrical and non-electrical “cold” loops during the same procedure might appear to be time-consuming. However, as well as in Formula 1 races, where the changing of tires at pit stop improves the car’s performance, by this technique, the complete dislocation of the intramural portion of the myoma into the uterine cavity leads to a faster and safer complete removal.
To our surprise, myoma grading was not significantly associated with any of the adverse perioperative and long-term outcome. Beyond fluid deficit, which was nearly similar in G1 and G2, all other surgical outcomes were not affected by grading in this cohort in which myomas were enucleated by cold loops and not by electrosurgical slicing. The 75th percentile of myoma mean diameter of this cohort was 3 cm. This occurred to be equal to the dimension cut-off value adopted by previous authors to differentiate small and large myomas [6, 21, 23]. This myoma mean diameter proved to be the only independent significant determinant correlated to perioperative surgical outcomes (operating time >50 min, fluid deficit ≥500 ml, surgical complications and incomplete resection at first procedure). These relevant data were strictly confirmed by the multiple regression analysis. Long-term outcomes (persisting symptoms and additional surgery for persisting symptoms) were not significantly different neither for the severity of grading nor for the myoma mean diameter and were comparable to those previously reported with a 7-year surgery-free rate of 87% [18, 24].
Operation time, fluid decifit and complete resection at first procedure were highly significantly correlated to myoma dimension >3 cm. The importance of myomas size underlines the debatable role of pre-surgical medical treatment with the aim to reduce large submucous myomas [25, 26]. GnRH analogues are significantly more efficacious on submucous when compared to the effect on intramural or subserosal myomas . However, its use in this series was not significant (Table 1), probably due to the higher technical difficulties arising in the removal of the myoma from the pseudocapsule.
Perioperative complications (fluid deficit >1,500 ml, uterine perforation and perioperative haemorrhage) occurred in ten cases (6%). These data were comparable to reported rates in series considering advanced hysteroscopic procedures, i.e. involving the myometrium [3, 19, 20].
The only uterine perforation occurred in a case with a coexisting intramural myoma adjacent to the submucous which prevented myometrial progressive thickening during enucleation as observed at sonography by Yang  and Casadio . This perforation occurred by using cold loops avoiding further thermal damage on surrounding organs.
The negligible number of synechiae (2.6%) and myometrial lesions (0.6%) are strictly correlated with the surgical technique, clearly demonstrating that no thermal damage by monopolar current into the myometrium is an important factor for the adhesion formation, significantly lower than the reported variable incidence of 7.5–45.5% [11, 17, 30]. These results, added to the high rate of G2 and >3 cm submucous myomas one-step complete resection (85% and 60%, respectively) and the low rate of intraoperative complications, clearly evidenced the proven practical advantages derived by the use of this combined electrical and non-electrical “cold” technique. Obstetric outcomes in infertile patients were satisfactory, with a pregnancy rate of 45%, similar to previously published data (36–45%) [31, 32].
Surgeon skills might be a remarkable bias in this series, being all procedures performed by an experienced hysteroscopist [3, 13, 23]. However, the learning curve analysis by comparing the first 50 procedures with the following did not detect any significant worse outcomes in the learning phase.
Although the study group was limited for the evaluation of short- and long-term complications, the population was very well defined and the surgical conditions were also well standardized (one technique, one operator and one centre).
In conclusion, hysteroscopic myomectomy by cold loops revealed to be an effective (low complication rate and high single-step complete resection) and efficient (day-surgery procedure and low long-term failure rate) surgical approach to the removal of submucous myoma with intramural development. Furthermore, by using this technique, myoma mean diameter proved to be the only prognostic factor of perioperative outcomes.
Conflicts of interest
The authors report no conflicts of interest. The authors alone are responsible for the content and writing of the paper.
- Hidlebaugh DA (2001) Relative costs of gynecologic endoscopy vs traditional surgery for treatment of abnormal uterine bleeding. Am J Manag Care 7:SP31–SP37PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Brumsted JR, Blackman JA, Badger GJ, Riddick DH (1996) Hysteroscopy versus hysterectomy for the treatment of abnormal uterine bleeding: a comparison of cost. Fertil Steril 65(2):310–316PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Di Spiezio SA, Mazzon I, Bramante S, Bettocchi S, Bifulco G, Guida M et al (2008) Hysteroscopic myomectomy: a comprehensive review of surgical techniques. Hum Reprod Update 14(2):101–119View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wamsteker K, Emanuel MH, de Kruif JH (1993) Transcervical hysteroscopic resection of submucous fibroids for abnormal uterine bleeding: results regarding the degree of intramural extension. Obstet Gynecol 82(5):736–740PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Emanuel MH, Hart A, Wamsteker K, Lammes F (1997) An analysis of fluid loss during transcervical resection of submucous myomas. Fertil Steril 68(5):881–886PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hart R, Molnar BG, Magos A (1999) Long term follow up of hysteroscopic myomectomy assessed by survival analysis. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 106(7):700–705PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Vercellini P, Zaina B, Yaylayan L, Pisacreta A, De Giorgi O, Crosignani PG (1999) Hysteroscopic myomectomy: long-term effects on menstrual pattern and fertility. Obstet Gynecol 94(3):341–347PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Darwish A, Zareh HZ (2002) Haemodynamic, biochemical and haematological changes during hysteroscopic myomectomy. Gynecol Endosc 11:349–355View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Baggish MS, Tucker RD (1995) Tissue actions of bipolar scissors compared with monopolar devices. Fertil Steril 63(2):422–426PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Munro MG, Fu YS (1995) Loop electrosurgical excision with a laparoscopic electrode and carbon dioxide laser vaporization: comparison of thermal injury characteristics in the rat uterine horn. Am J Obstet Gynecol 172(4 Pt 1):1257–1262PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yang JH, Chen MJ, Wu MY, Chao KH, Ho HN, Yang YS (2008) Office hysteroscopic early lysis of intrauterine adhesion after transcervical resection of multiple apposing submucous myomas. Fertil Steril 89(5):1254–1259PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Mazzon I (1995) Nuova tecnica per la miomectomia isteroscopica: enucleazione con ansa fredda.In Testo-Atlante di Chirurgia Endoscopica Ginecologica. Edited by E Cittadini, A Perino, M Angiolillo, et al. Palermo, Italy, Cofese Ed.Google Scholar
- Camanni M, Bonino L, Delpiano EM, Ferrero B, Migliaretti G, Deltetto F (2010) Hysteroscopic management of large symptomatic submucous uterine myomas. J Minim Invasive Gynecol 17(1):59–65PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Leone FP, Lanzani C, Ferrazzi E (2003) Use of strict sonohysterographic methods for preoperative assessment of submucous myomas. Fertil Steril 79(4):998–1002PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Leone FP, Bignardi T, Marciante C, Ferrazzi E (2007) Sonohysterography in the preoperative grading of submucous fibroids: considerations on three-dimensional methodology. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 29:717–718PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Loffer FD, Bradley LD, Brill AI, Brooks PG, Cooper JM (2000) Hysteroscopic fluid monitoring guidelines. J Am Assoc Gynecol Laparosc 7(1):167–168PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Touboul C, Fernandez H, Deffieux X et al (2009) Uterine synechiae after bipolar hysteroscopic resection of submucosal myomas in patients with infertility. Fertil Steril 92:1690PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Emanuel MH, Wamsteker K, Hart AA, Metz G, Lammes FB (1999) Long-term results of hysteroscopic myomectomy for abnormal uterine bleeding. Obstet Gynecol 93(5 Pt 1):743–748PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Cravello L, Agostini A, Beerli M, Roger V, Bretelle F, Blanc B (2004) Results of hysteroscopic myomectomy. Gynecol Obstet Fertil 32(9):825–828PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Polena V, Mergui JL, Perrot N, Poncelet C, Barranger E, Uzan S (2007) Long-term results of hysteroscopic myomectomy in 235 patients. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 130(2):232–237PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lasmar RB, Xinmei Z, Indman PD, Celeste RK, Di Spiezio SA (2011) Feasibility of a new system of classification of submucous myomas: a multicenter study. Fertil Steril 95(6):2073–2077PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- de Ziegler D, Bulletti C, Fanchin R, Epiney M, Brioschi PA (2001) Contractility of the nonpregnant uterus: the follicular phase. Ann N Y Acad Sci 943:172–184PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Donnez J, Polet R, Smets M, Bassil S, Nisolle M (1995) Hysteroscopic myomectomy. Curr Opin Obstet Gyencol 7:311–316Google Scholar
- Cravello L, Farnarier J, Roger V, D’Ercole C, Blanc B (1998) Hysteroscopic myomectomy. Functional results with an average follow-up of 6 years. J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod (Paris) 27(6):593–597Google Scholar
- Muzii L, Boni T, Bellati F, Marana R, Ruggiero A, Zullo MA et al (2010) GnRH analogue treatment before hysteroscopic resection of submucous myomas: a prospective, randomized, multicenter study. Fertil Steril 94(4):1496–1499PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Mavrelos D, Ben-Nagi J, Davies A, Lee C, Salim R, Jurkovic D (2010) The value of pre-operative treatment with GnRH analogues in women with submucous fibroids: a double-blind, placebo-controlled randomized trial. Hum Reprod 25(9):2264–2269PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Brosens J, Campo R, Gordts S, Brosens I (2003) Submucous and outer myometrium leiomyomas are two distinct clinical entities. Fertil Steril 79(6):1452–1454PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yang JH, Lin BL (2001) Changes in myometrial thickness during hysteroscopic resection of deeply invasive submucous myomas. J Am Assoc Gynecol Laparosc 8(4):501–505PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Casadio P, Youssef AM, Spagnolo E, Rizzo MA, Talamo MR, De Angelis D et al (2011) Should the myometrial free margin still be considered a limiting factor for hysteroscopic resection of submucous fibroids? A possible answer to an old question. Fertil Steril 95(5):1764–1768PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Taskin O, Sadik S, Onoglu A, Gokdeniz R, Erturan E, Burak F, Wheeler JM (2000) Role of endometrial suppression on the frequency of intrauterine adhesions after resectoscopic surgery. J Am Assoc Gynecol Laparosc 7(3):351–354PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Somigliana E, Vercellini P, Daguati R, Pasin R, De Giorgi O, Crosignani PG (2007) Fibroids and female reproduction: a critical analysis of the evidence. Hum Reprod Update 13:465–476PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Shokeir T, El-Shafei M, Yousef H, Allam AF, Sadek E (2010) Submucous myomas and their implications in the pregnancy rates of patients with otherwise unexplained primary infertility undergoing hysteroscopic myomectomy: a randomized matched control study. Fertil Steril 94(2):724–729PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar