A 4-cm G2 cervical submucosal myoma removed with the IBS® Integrated Bigatti Shaver
© The Author(s) 2012
Received: 22 January 2012
Accepted: 8 February 2012
Published: 3 March 2012
KeywordsIBS® Shaver Operative hysteroscopy New instrumentation
At present conventional bipolar resectoscopy is widely recognized as first choice procedure for major hysteroscopic operations [1, 2]. We have proposed an alternative approach to operative hysteroscopy called IBS® Integrated Bigatti Shaver  that improving the visualization during the procedure, as the tissue chips are removed from the uterine cavity at the same time of resection, reduces several problems of conventional resectoscopy such as fluid overload and water intoxication with a lower risk of uterine perforation. In cooperation with Karl Storz GmbH & Co., we have created a new shaving system that, introduced through a straight operative channel of a panoramic 90° optic, allows performing all kinds of major hysteroscopic operations. We have recently published the first randomized comparative study , designed in order to compare 50 cases performed with conventional bipolar resectoscope with 50 cases performed with the IBS®. All kinds of major intrauterine pathologies such as polyps up to 6 cm and G0, G1 and G2 sub-mucosal myomas, classified according to the ESGE guidelines, up to 3 cm in diameter were included in the study . Dilatation time, global time of the procedure, resection time and fluid balance were carefully monitorized during each procedure of the two groups of patients.
The result of this study confirmed the several advantages offered by the IBS® such as better visualization during the procedure as tissue chips were removed at the same time of resection, no coagulation or cutting current was needed, utilization of normal saline and a much faster learning curve. In addition the 24 Fr total diameter of the optic allows a dilatation of the cervix up to number 8.5 of Hegar reducing the risk of cervical laceration and uterine perforation.
We could approach all kind of polyps and myomas up to 3 cm in a very fast, precise and clean way. The only drawback of this technique was represented by myomas with higher consistency and with a diameter larger than 3 cm. For this reason we have designed two new blades, number 6 which has a flute beak shape and number 7 which resemble the shark jaws in order to be more aggressive in cutting the fibrotic tissue. We report this interesting case in which the IBS® was able to remove in a two-step procedure a very large cervical G2 submucosal myoma, considered one of the most difficult cases to approach by conventional resectoscopy.
A 37-year-old primiparous young patient came to our attention for menometrorrhagic cycles and intermenstrual bleeding. A transvaginal ultrasound was performed showing a posterior intracervical submucosal myoma of more than 4 cm in diameter. Diagnostic hysteroscopy confirmed the diagnosis, and we were able to assess that the largest part of the myoma was intramural and therefore classify the myoma as a G2 type.
This case report confirms our thesis that almost all major hysteroscopic surgical procedures can be performed with the IBS® in a very easy, fast, precise and safe way. Especially for the treatment of large myomas up to 3 cm, it has several well-described advantages. As discussed by Emanuel et al., the diameter of an intrauterine pathology is strongly related to the operation time and to the complication rate . Considering the volume calculation of the tissue to remove by the formula 4/3πr3, we need 8.4 min to resect 2 cm, 28.2 min for 3 cm and 67.0 min for 4 cm at a resection speed of 0.5 cm3/min for a conventional monopolar loop. Also in this case, the IBS® seems to be much faster than the conventional resectoscope. Probably this is due to the fact that the continuous cutting capacity performed always under direct visual control, with immediate removal of the chips at time of resection, results in a more efficient reduction of the tumour volume. Not only operation time but also total fluid loss seems to be better with the IBS® system. In fact the mean fluid deficit of the two procedures was limited to 750 ml with a mean of total fluid used of 9,250 ml. In addition the main advantage of the IBS® was that the myoma was effectively enucleated from its fovea and the intramural site of insertion of the myoma was removed. The surrounding healthy endometrium was avoided without any thermal injury occurring, compared with the less precise behaviour of conventional resectoscopy. No coagulation was needed, and there were no excess bleeding problems. At last, the approach of submucosal cervical myomas is considered one of the most difficult cases in operative hysteroscopy. The visibility during the procedure is reduced by the fact that the wall of the cervical canal blocks the holes of the aspiration system, placed at the lateral site of the outer sheet tip of the conventional resectoscope. The IBS® has a different aspiration system, directly from the front part of the tip, that always allows, especially in the treatment of intracervical pathologies, a better visualization. By the analysis of a small series of cases performed with blade number 6 and 7, which has to be confirmed by further studies, we found out that is not the size nor the sharpness of the blade but the consistency of the myoma the parameter that has to be considered in order to improve our cutting capability. We believe that the success of this case was also due to the reduced consistency of this myoma associated with a higher cutting power of our blades.
For very large myomas, we will possibly need to improve our blade system because at present the IBS® has still some drawbacks. Compared to other blind intrauterine applications, the IBS® has the major advantage that surgeons always perform the procedure under visual control, with automated and easy removal of tissue chips. Very interesting is that the IBS® is able to resect also myomatous tissue, making this a very promising alternative to the resectoscope. In fact surgery is not interrupted by tissue chips removal, making total operating time shorter. It is further postulated that resection of myomas without the use of electrical current could significantly reduce the postoperative adhesion formation and that the IBS® should preferentially be used in younger women in their reproductive age .
We believe that the success in removing such a large cervical myoma with the IBS® supports our thesis that we are working in the right direction. Certainly the IBS® is at the beginning of its history and can only be improved in its functionality. At present we are testing the possibility of a bipolar coagulation system through the operative channel of the optic in order to prevent possible bleeding in the treatment of large myomas. Anyway the mechanical removal of pathological tissues from the uterine cavity without the use of current makes the procedure much safer. Further studies are planned in order to confirm the real value of the IBS® in the treatment of submucosal myomas.
Declaration of interest
The authors report no conflicts of interest. The authors alone are responsible for the content and writing of the paper.
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits any use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author(s) and the source are credited.
- Di Spezio SA, Mazzon I, Bramante S, Bettocchi S, Bifulco G, Guida M, Nappi C (2008) Hysteroscopic myomectomy: a comprehensive review of surgical techniques. Hum Reprod Updat 14(2):101–119View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Oona Hamerlynck TW, Dietz V, Schoot BC (2011) Clinical implementation of the hysteroscopic morcellator for removal of intrauterine myomas and polyps. A retrospective descriptive study. Gynecol Surg 8:193–196View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bigatti G (2011) IBS® Integrated Bigatti Shaver, an alternative approach to operative hysteroscopy. Gynecol Surg 8(2):187View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bigatti G, Ferrario C, MD, Rosales M, Baglioni A, Bianchi S (2011) IBS® Integrated Bigatti Shaver versus conventional bipolar resectoscopy: a randomized comparative study. Gynecol Surg (in press)Google Scholar
- Emanuel MH, Wamsteker K (2005) The intrauterine morcellator: a new hysteroscopic operating technique to remove intrauterine polyps and myomas. J Minim Invasive Gynecol 12(1):65–66View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Emanuel MH, Hart A, Wamsteker K, Lammes F (1997) An analysis of fluid loss during transcervical resection of submucous myomas. Fertil Steril 68(5):881–886PubMedView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wamsteker K, Emanuel MH, de Kruif JH (1993) Transcervical hysteroscopic resection of submucous fibroids for abnormal uterine bleeding: result regarding the degree of intramural extension. Obstet Gynecol 82:736–740PubMedGoogle Scholar